Leila Bird | Electronic+ | Getty Images
New research suggests a popular retirement strategy known as the 4% rule may need some recalibration in 2025 based on market conditions.
The 4% rule helps retirees determine how much they can withdraw from their accounts each year and be relatively confident that they won’t run out of money over a 30-year retirement period.
Under this strategy, retirees use 4% of their savings in the first year. For future withdrawals, they adjust the prior year’s dollar amount upward for inflation.
But Morningstar said the “safe” withdrawal rate fell from 4% in 2024 to 3.7% in 2025 due to long-term assumptions in financial markets. Research.
More from Personal Finance:
Best Tax Brackets for Roth IRA Conversions
Senate plans to vote on Social Security bill for some pensioners
The ‘shock’ is over as optimism grows
Specifically, Morningstar analysts said expectations for returns on stocks, bonds and cash over the next 30 years have declined compared with last year. This means that a portfolio split 50-50 between stocks and bonds will grow less.
Christine Benz, director of personal finance and retirement planning at Morningstar, said that while history shows the 4 percent rule is a “reasonable starting point,” if retirees are willing to have the flexibility to adjust their annual spending, they often It’s okay to deviate from your retirement strategy.
That could mean spending less in down markets, she said.
“We caution that the assumptions underpinning (the 4% rule) are very conservative,” Bentz said. “The last thing we want to do is scare people or encourage people to spend less.”
How the 4% rule works
Andrews De | Electronic+ | Getty Images
In many ways, saving less is harder than saving more.
Withdrawing too much money early in retirement—especially during a market downturn—often increases a saver’s likelihood of saving. All the money is spent in old age.
There is also the opposite risk, that of being too conservative and living beyond your means.
The 4% rule is designed to guide retirees to relative safety.
Here’s an example of how it works: An investor withdraws $40,000 from a $1 million portfolio in the first year of retirement. If the cost of living increases by 2% that year, next year’s withdrawal amount will increase to $40,800. etc.
Historically, from 1926 to 1993, this formula resulted in 90% of money remaining after as long as 30 years of retirement, according to Morningstar.
Using the 3.7% rule, first-year withdrawals for a hypothetical $1 million portfolio drop to $37,000.
That said, there are some drawbacks to the structure of the 4% Rule, according to a 2024 Charles Schwab report article Written by Chris Kawashima, Director of Financial Planning and Rob Williams, Managing Director of Financial Planning, Retirement Income and Wealth Management.
For example, it doesn’t include taxes or investment fees, and works for a “very specific” portfolio — a 50-50 stock-bond mix that doesn’t change over time, they wrote.
It’s also “rigid,” Kawashima and Williams said.
The rule “assumes you will never spend more or less than the increase in inflation,” they wrote. “This is not how most people spend in retirement. Spending may change from one year to the next, and the amount you spend may change throughout retirement.”
How Retirees Can Adjust the 4% Rule
Bentz said retirees can make some tweaks and tweaks to the 4% rule.
For example, Bentz said retirees typically spend less in their postretirement years on an inflation-adjusted basis. If retirees can enter retirement and are comfortable spending less later, that means they can safely increase spending early in retirement, Bentz said.
This trade-off would yield a first-year safe withdrawal rate of 4.8% in 2025, significantly higher than the aforementioned 3.7%, according to Morningstar.
At the same time, Bentz said long-term care is a big “variable” that could increase retirees’ expenses later in life. For example, the average American will pay about $6,300 per month for a home health aide and $8,700 for a semi-private room in a nursing home by 2023, according to the latest data from Genworth. care costs study.
In addition, Bentz said, when the market rises significantly in a given year, investors may be able to add some money to themselves, and when the market falls, investors can withdraw less.
If possible, delaying taking Social Security until age 70 — thereby increasing monthly monthly payments for life — could be a way for many retirees to increase their financial security, if possible, she said. federal government Add to If you delay claiming Social Security benefits, you pay 8% of your benefits for each full year full retirement ageuntil the age of 70.
However, this calculation depends on where families get the cash to delay the Social Security age. For example, Benz says it’s better to continue to live off your job income than to rely heavily on your investment portfolio to cover living expenses until age 70.
About The Author
